A List Of NYC’s Most Haunted Places
Source: Squarespace/ Unsplash
A Haunted NYC
New York City is known for its vibrant culture, iconic skyline, and bustling streets, but beneath its modern charm lies a history rich with ghostly tales and supernatural lore. Ghost culture in New York City is a fascinating blend of folklore, urban legends, and the city’s rich historical tapestry.
Ghost culture is popular in the city’s thriving arts scene, with theater productions, haunted tours, and literature keeping these eerie narratives alive. It also reflects the city’s diversity, incorporating ghost stories from immigrant communities, each bringing unique traditions and perspectives to NYC’s supernatural lore.
With its centuries-old buildings, hidden tunnels, and storied past, NYC is rife with tales of restless spirits said to haunt various locations throughout the city. For those intrigued by the paranormal, NYC offers a chilling array of haunted locations where the past refuses to rest. Here are some of the most haunted places in the city:
The House of Death – 14 West 10th Street
Dubbed the "House of Death," this Greenwich Village brownstone is said to host the spirits of 22 former residents. The building is a 4 story walk-up with 10 units according to streeteasy. One of its most famous inhabitants was Mark Twain, who lived there briefly in the early 1900s. Residents and visitors have reported seeing Twain’s apparition, as well as hearing unexplained footsteps and whispers.
The building’s ominous reputation was solidified in the 1980s when a tragic murder occurred within its walls, adding another layer to its eerie legacy. A child had passed away due to abuse from her parents. The fact that this murder occurred in a location that had been deemed haunted further validates the superstitions people have about the house.
The Dakota – 1 West 72nd Street
This iconic luxury apartment building, constructed in 1884 on Central Park West and 72nd Street, features a steep roof, dormer windows, corner pavilions, and architectural details that blend German Renaissance and Gothic Revival styles. It’s precisely the sort of place where you might imagine spirits lingering.
The Dakota’s most well-known ghost is that of a little girl seen roaming the hallways. Other residents have reported strange noises, objects moving on their own, and ghostly figures. The building gained further notoriety as the site of John Lennon’s tragic death in 1980, and some claim his spirit lingers nearby.
The Merchant’s House Museum – 29 East 4th Street
Preserved as a 19th-century time capsule, the Merchant’s House Museum is home to the Tredwell family’s spirits. Gertrude Tredwell, the last surviving member of the family, is believed to haunt the house. Visitors and staff have reported cold spots, mysterious sounds, and sightings of a woman in period clothing. Paranormal investigators frequently cite the museum as one of NYC’s most haunted locations.
The Landmarks Preservation Commission approved a development adjacent to the Merchant’s House that threatens to destroy one of New York’s earliest landmarks—a family home built in 1832 that has remained fully intact, both inside and out. This vital and irreplaceable piece of New York’s history is at risk of being lost forever.
Washington Square Park
Beneath the lively atmosphere of Washington Square Park lies a darker and often forgotten history. Before it became a bustling hub for artists, musicians, and tourists, the park served as a potter’s field in the early 19th century, where thousands of bodies were laid to rest in unmarked graves. Many of these were victims of the devastating yellow fever epidemics that swept through New York City, while others met their end through public executions carried out beneath the infamous hanging tree that once stood in the park. Over the years, numerous eerie accounts have emerged from those who visit after dark, reporting ghostly apparitions, disembodied whispers, and an unsettling sense of being watched. Some believe these unexplained phenomena are the work of the restless spirits buried beneath the park, forever tied to the land that once bore witness to their suffering and untimely deaths.
The Morris-Jumel Mansion – 65 Jumel Terrace
As Manhattan’s oldest surviving house, the Morris-Jumel Mansion is steeped in history—and ghosts. Formerly George Washington’s headquarters during the Revolutionary War, the mansion is said to be haunted by Eliza Jumel, a socialite who lived there in the 19th century.
The hauntings began soon after her death at age 90 in 1865, as Eliza was allegedly seen wandering about the property in a white dress and producing spine-tingling noises. Visitors have reported seeing her apparition, hearing disembodied voices, and feeling an unshakable presence in the house.
St. Mark’s Church in-the-Bowery – 131 East 10th Street
This historic church is one of NYC’s oldest sites of worship, and its graveyard is believed to be haunted by Peter Stuyvesant, the last Dutch leader of New Amsterdam. Peter Stuyvesant is an important figure in American history because of his role as the last Dutch Director-General of the New Netherland colony, which later became New York. He governed from 1647 until the English took control of the colony in 1664. Stuyvesant's leadership and decisions had a significant impact on the development of the region that would eventually become one of the most important parts of the United States.
His ghost is said to roam the church grounds, sometimes accompanied by the sound of his peg leg tapping on the floor. Other eerie occurrences include ghostly voices and shadowy figures.
The Algonquin Hotel – 59 West 44th Street
Known for its literary legacy, the Algonquin Hotel is also said to harbor a few spectral residents. Guests and staff have reported unusual activity, such as flickering lights, unexplained noises, and the feeling of being watched. Some believe the spirits of former Round Table members linger, ensuring their witty banter lives on.
The Round Table at the Algonquin Hotel refers to a famous group of writers, critics, and intellectuals who regularly met for lunch at the hotel's restaurant in New York City during the 1920s. The group was known for its wit, literary discussions, and sharp humor. They became iconic in the literary world, and their gatherings at the Algonquin, a prestigious hotel located at 59th Street and Lexington Avenue, were a focal point of New York's literary scene at the time.
The Round Table was primarily a group of authors, but it included other prominent figures in the arts, such as theater critics, columnists, and actors. Key members of the group included:
Dorothy Parker, a famous poet, short story writer, and satirist, known for her sharp wit.
Robert Benchley, a humorist, journalist, and actor.
Harold Ross, the founding editor of The New Yorker.
George S. Kaufman, a playwright and director.
Alexander Woollcott, a critic, commentator, and author.
The group is often remembered for their sarcastic humor, social critiques, and the playful yet intellectually stimulating conversations they had over lunch. The Round Table also helped to launch the careers of several key literary figures and contributed to the cultural atmosphere of the Jazz Age and the Roaring Twenties in New York.
Wrap Up
New York City’s haunted history adds a spooky dimension to its allure. Whether you’re a skeptic or a believer, these locations offer a glimpse into the city’s spectral side. Next time you’re wandering the streets of NYC, remember: you might not be alone.
